What is wrong with playgroups?
May 31, 2007and why are so many people so quick to categorically diss other parents on the playground?
It seems to have become fashionable to talk about how much one loathes other parents and their children, almost as fashionable as it is to talk about how much one loathes being a parent to one’s own children. I am seriously losing my sense of humor about it. It is like some strange form of cannibalism.
I live in a city and I have no family nearby. I know it is important to be social, for myself and for my child. That’s about the extent of it. So I found them online. Yes, my son and I *gasp* “belong” to a playgroup.
Sometimes I wish I lived in a neighborhood with more kids. I often wish we lived in a friendlier society in general. Social spontaneity is certainly ideal, it’s just not realistic. I will admit, I had to psych myself up to go to my first meetup. Get this - I was concerned that the people at that first meetup were going to be like the cariacatures depicted in many a painfully hip blog and messageboard posting. I believed the hype! I was apprehensive, but I did know that if it didn’t go well, it would likely be due to my social anxiety rather than a reflection of the people there.
Fortunately, there was a meetup at the coffee shop across the street a few months back. I figured that if I felt truly uncomfortable, no harm done. We would just cross the street again and return home. It turned out to be great. So great that it has actually turned into a few spontaneous walks, play meetups and dinners. Once, when I reallyreallyreally didn’t want to go to a playgroup, when I couldn’t figure out how to get out the freaking door between napping and pumping and all that, when I couldn’t seem to stop crying and I was embarrassed by my swollen and tear-streaky face, I went anyway. Even though I so wanted to be alone, the fresh air and just being around other people saved the day for me and Bean.
I recently had breakfast with another mom and baby I met at that first meetup, and I had to psych myself up for that, too. I am glad I did. The conversation waned a bit at times, and unless I actively engaged her otherwise, it was solely baby-centered. That got on my nerves a little, and we clearly have different ways of approaching parenting, but it was no more awkward than any other first date I’ve ever had. Am I really supposed to expect that our words will tumble over one another’s, that we will reach for the last roll in the bread basket at the same time, brush hands and giggle together; that we will finish each other’s sentences and still be there talking with our magically serene Ann Geddes babies until the staff is sweeping up the joint? Didn’t happen. Does that mean I am supposed to categorize and diss her now, because I co-sleep and breastfeed in public and am currently unemployed, while she has the opposite of each happening in her life? How about the fact that she ordered all sweet stuff while I ordered savory, and I was concerned about giving Bean the restaurant’s tap water while she let her kiddo slurp away? Should we divide ourselves according to these preferences as well?
Do some of us so miss the drama and fretful entanglements of past dating relationships that we recreate them with parents we meet?
Even after a few months of going (when we can get out the door on time), I do still have to psych myself up to go to playgroups. Once *gasp* I even hosted. And oh my fucking stars, we had a fun. Imagine that! Babies. Like. Each. Other. Parents. Can. Suspend. Judgement.
So yeah, yours truly, the daughter and heir of a shyness that is criminally vulgar, is here to say that everybody needs to relax with the parenttyping. Granted, Chicago is a particularly cool city, filled with particularly cool people, so maybe that is why I do not find myself contending with neighborhood nazis that are label-y, milestone-y, Baby Einstein dogmatists. Still, I am actually wondering how many of those people really exist outside of the interweb and the desire to write paid ad-attracting posts. It’s like I said (somewhere in) here, some parents seem to have never left the bully-or-be-bullied, I-will-reject-you-before-you-reject-me constraints of their grade school commons. I know the coolest kids were the ones who could make others feel the most uncool, but we are all growed up now.
Who knows, though. Maybe some parent groups really are bitingly exclusive. Maybe some really are blatantly label conscious and rudely competitive. Or maybe they just have some people in them who are insecure about their new role as parents, and are overcompensating by laying on the inflated opinions a bit thick. Maybe they are just trying to relate to others in a misguided fashion.
So far I have found it pretty easy to deflect anything that strikes me as way out there. I am in no way socially graceful, I am just not threatened by insecure behavior. If anything, the label whores and histrionic opinionators probably need to receive some kindness to help them relax. They’ve probably read to many parenting books and are all freaked out. If you do encounter one who expounds some wacky parenting shit to you, offer them a cocktail or juicebox, nod and say, “I can respect that” and either change the subject or talk to someone else. Abracadabra.
Do I sound annoyingly well-adjusted and self-actualized? I’m not. I just don’t see the point in ripping on each other, even under the guise of humor. Learning to be a parent is hard enough. So let’s all just share some banana puffs and calm the fuck down.
Posted by Bianca Bean










