“When we trust the makers of baby formula more than we do our own ability to nourish our babies, we lose a chance to claim an aspect of our power as women. Thinking that baby formula is as good as breast milk is believing that thirty years of technology is superior to three million years of nature’s evolution. Countless women have regained trust in their bodies through nursing their children, even if they weren’t sure at first that they could do it. It is an act of female power, and I think of it as feminism in its purest form.”
—– Christine Northrup M.D.
I am not a doctor, but I play one in my mind.
So when my sister asked me the other day if I would “think less of” her if she decided to not breastfeed when she has a baby, it got me thinking. Her only experience with breastfeeding has been to watch the struggle that Baby Bean and I had to make it happen for us (we had complications from a long labor and emergency c-section, my milk didn’t come in properly as a result of all the interventions, we were often separated, then we got thrush, you get the point). First, let me say that for me to think “less” of anyone, for any decisions they make, would be pretty damn rare. I’ve known lot of people who have had some pretty interesting lifestyles and made a lot of choices that I wouldn’t make for myself, but I very rarely thought “less” of anyone for it. The thing is, though, I do have a very strong opinion about at least trying to breastfeed, that would maybe make some people freak out pretty hard, but here it is…
Formula was created as an intervention, as a way to save babies’ lives when things weren’t going well. It was my mother’s generation that got it into their heads that formula was superior to breastmilk, thanks to their well-meaning doctors who were on a whole “wave of the future” kick, as well as a pretty uptight culture that sexualized the female breast to a fault. Based on what we know now about the benefits of breastmilk, and the possibility of detrimental effects of some formulas in some circumstances, I feel that if you aren’t at least willing to try to breastfeed, then you shouldn’t plan to have a baby just yet, because you may not be ready for the commitment it takes to raise another human being (of course this excludes adoptions and other circumstances, don’t get silly on me).
I didn’t choose to breastfeed for me; it was uncomfortable as hell, and at times very painful. The lactation consultants I dealt with were more harmful than helpful. I also faced a lot of weird scrutiny from my family (said sister feels as though I would be like a pedophile if I continued to breastfeed Baby Bean until he is a year old). Like I said though, I don’t do it for me, I do it for Baby Bean. Deciding that you will not try to breastfeed, for non-medical reasons, is like scheduling a c–section that isn’t medically necessary because you have decided that it is too inconvenient to push. It’s like saying you want to have a baby, but carrying it for 9 months just is just going to be too uncomfortable, so you are going to take the baby out a few months early and grow it in a synthetic womb-like structure that is almost as good as the real thing. That being said, if you do try, and it doesn’t work out despite your best efforts, then of course use formula. It would be just as if you baby could not be birthed naturally due to complications, and an intervention like a c–section was needed. Formula is an intervention to be used when a mother cannot breastfeed, not a first choice for the sake of convenience or discomfort.
Now before you start thinking of me as a lactivist extremist, let me reiterate that I do not think “less” of anyone for choices they make for themselves, whether I agree with them or not. I do certainly realize that breastfeeding is affected by socioeconomics and is not feasible as a long-term option for many women. All I am saying is that every woman, barring medical reasons, should be encouraged to try for as long as she can, whether it is a week, a month, or a year.
I am very fortunate that I had the money for an inexpensive but decent pump that I used while I was separated from Baby Bean. I am fortunate that I had access to literature about breastfeeding to inform my choice to keep trying. I am fortunate I was able to continue to work on breastfeeding with Baby Bean for 10 weeks while I supplemented with formula. I am fortunate that Huz encouraged me when I would cry and want to give up. My sister will be in the same fortunate situation as me, so to say that she will not even try to breastfeed based on reasons such as her physical and emotional discomfort, even though she has access to the same equipment, literature, and support as I did; this is what makes me question her readiness to have a baby at all. The funny thing is, I didn’t even know I had an opinion about it until she asked me.
Postscript: Since I wrote this, she has said that she would try for the first week, because she knows how important the colostrum is. I hadn’t said a word about how I felt, and she doesn’t know about this blog…maybe my opinion burned like a laser beam out of my eye sockets and somehow etched itself on her subconcious! I wonder if I can do this to others. Hmmmm, the possibilities, mwuah-ha-ha-ha-haaaaaaaaaaaa!